Testimony
of the
American Nurses Association
before the
Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services,
Education and Related Agencies
Committee on Appropriations
United States House of Representatives
Presented by
Mary E. Foley, RN, MS
President
April 4, 2000
2:00 P.M.
The American Nurses Association (ANA) appreciates this opportunity to comment on Fiscal Year (FY)
2001 appropriations for nursing education, nursing research and workforce programs. ANA is the only
full-service professional organization representing the nation's 2.6 million registered nurses, including
staff nurses, nurse practitioners, clinical nurse specialists, certified nurse midwives and certified
registered nurse anesthetists through its 53 state and territorial nurses associations.
ANA gratefully acknowledges this Subcommittee's support for nursing education and research. We
appreciate your continued recognition of the important role nurses play in the delivery of health care
services and the increased need to fund nursing education programs and innovative practice models.
Today, the changing demographics of American society and the health care delivery system demand a
nursing workforce that has a sound foundation in a broad range of basic sciences, as well as a unique
set of critical thinking and problem solving skills. Unfortunately, the nursing community at large is
starting to observe a shortage of nurses with competence, skills and experience to meet the current
demand for more complex patient care. Most recently, findings from the 1999-2000 Enrollment and
Graduations in Baccalaureate and Graduate Programs in Nursing survey done by the American
Association of Colleges of Nursing report a decrease in enrollments of nursing students in entry-level
bachelor's-degree programs. Therefore, we believe that our shared goal of ensuring the nation of an
adequate supply of well-educated nurses, to meet the increasing demands of our rapidly changing health
care system, will reaffirm the need for increased funding of these programs. Today, ANA offers our
professional recommendations for federal funding of nursing education, nursing research and workforce
programs.
Department of Health and Human Servcies Programs
Nurse Educaiton Act
Advanced practice nurses - registered nurses with education and clinical experience generally at a
master's degree level - are providing primary care services in place of physicians or are providing an
expanded type of primary care, either as nurse practitioners, certified nurse midwives or clinical nurse
specialists. Due to the continued changes in our health care delivery system and the changing
demographics and complexity of care, nurse practitioners will be in increasing demand and the nurse
education system will be stretched to provide first-quality training for them. These changes call for the
fullest utilization possible of the multi-disciplinary providers who care for patients and families in an
ever-increasing array of settings: hospitals, subacute care facilities, rehabilitation facilities, long term care
facilities, schools and universities, workplaces and communities.
Federal support for nursing education in Title VIII of the Public Health Service Act (PHSA) is
unduplicated and essential to achieve future goals for the public's health. When Congress reauthorized
these programs by enacting "The Health Professions Partnership Act of 1998," P.L. 105-392, it
provided the Secretary of Health and Human Services broad discretion to determine which projects to
fund, with priority given to projects which would substantially benefit rural or underserved populations,
including public health departments. Under the improved Nurse Education Act (NEA) included in P.L.
105-392, the Division of Nursing has the needed flexibility to focus on curriculum development and
other programs to address the changing health care environment and assist in the preparation of more
nurses who are able to function where there is a greater demand. NEA will better address the need for
increasing the numbers of minority nurses available to provide culturally competent, linguistically
appropriate health care services to underserved communities by providing funding to support projects
that would increase nursing education opportunities for individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds.
These nurses would then be better prepared to assist these populations in changing the way they access
our health care system, and in helping these patients understand the advantages of developing
relationships with primary providers. By itself, the behavior change from accessing health care services
through emergency departments, to one in which the consumer routinely seeks care through a primary
provider, decreases health care costs exponentially.
Since the recent reauthorization of NEA allows for a more responsive approach to addressing health
care needs, it is crucial that the Division of Nursing be provided with the funding necessary to effectively
implement these programs. For FY 2000, due to the work of this Subcommittee, the Nurse Education
Act was funded at $67.8 million. For FY 2001, though the Administration's request is level
funding, we are requesting an increase in funding of 15 percent over FY 2000 to fund the Nurse
Education Act programs at approximately $78 million. In the FY 1999 funding cycle 174
applications were approved but only 39 percent or 68 of the approved applications received awards.
The NEA authorities are as follows:
Advanced education nurses: Advanced education nurses are registered nurses trained in advanced
degree programs, generally at a master's degree level. They provide primary care in lieu of physicians
or provide an expanded type of primary care. This category includes nurse practitioners, nurse
midwives, nurse anesthetists, clinical nurse specialists, nurse administrators, public health nurses and
other nurses as determined by the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services.
Traineeships for advanced nursing education is provided under this category. Title VIII funds have
supported the development of virtually all initial State and regional outreach models which first
demonstrated the delivery of part or all of a graduate program to students at sites using distance learning
methodologies from university settings thereby providing advanced study opportunities for nurses in
rural and remote areas. Title VIII funds currently support 68 Nurse Practitioner/Nurse Midwifery
programs. Ninety-five percent of these graduates work in primary care settings and 46 percent of
graduates work in medically underserved communities.
Programs to increase workforce diversity: Both overutilization of costly emergency services and
decreased access to primary care have been associated with a low representation of minority health care
providers. This legislation provides for increased flexibility in the use of funds to enhance diversity in
nursing education and practice. It supports projects to increase nursing education opportunities for
individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds - - including racial and ethnic minorities. Some support
will be provided through student scholarships or stipends and can be used for pre-entry preparation and
retention activities. Continued funding for programs that access this type of funding is dependent on
demonstrated outcomes. Title VIII funds currently support 22 projects with 1096 racial/ethnic minority
participants out of a total of 1597 disadvantaged participants.
Projects to strengthen the capacity of basic nursing education: Funding under this category assists
toward expanding basic nurse education, thereby enhancing the basic nursing workforce. Priority areas
identified include: skills development for practice in organized health care systems; nursing practice
arrangements, care for underserved populations and other high risk groups; cultural competency;
baccalaureate enrollment; career mobility; informatics education, including distance learning
methodologies and other areas as needed. Nurse managed clinics are included under this category.
During the past several years, data show that nurse-managed centers provide an average of 130,000
primary care encounters per year to individuals from vulnerable and underserved populations. Thirty-three nurse managed centers are currently supported by Title VIII funds. Additionally, six cooperative
agreements designed to facilitate and expedite baccalaureate education for registered nurses in rural
areas using distance learning methodologies were awarded in September 1999.
Nurse Loan Repayment (Section 836)
This program provides for up to 85 percent repayment of student loans for nurses who agree to a service
payback in nursing shortage areas. We recommend funding at $2.3 million.
Title VII of the Public Health Service Act
In reference to the FY 2001 Title VII funding proposed by the Administration, ANA does not support
the Administration's proposed elimination of the primary care and dentistry, geriatric, and public health
training programs at a time when continued shortages of primary care providers still exist in certain
parts of the country.
National Institute of Nursing Research (NINR)
The second funding priority for nursing is funding for the NINR, on the campus of the National Institutes
of Health (NIH). Again we applaud this Subcommittee's commitment to advancing behavioral science
research. Nursing research is an integral part of the effectiveness of nursing care. The NINR provides
the knowledge base for practice of 2.6 million registered nurses. Advances in nursing care arising from
nursing and other biomedical research improves the quality of patient care and has shown excellent
progress in reducing health care costs and health care demands. Research programs supported by the
NINR address a number of critical public health and patient care questions. The research is driven by
real and immediate problems encountered by patients and families. Study results offer the clear prospect
of improving health, reducing morbidity and mortality, and lowering costs and demand for health care.
Increased funding would enable an NINR initiative to develop and test interventions to help children with
asthma and their parents prevent asthma attacks, monitor airway inflammation, and manage daily
routines of care at home and at school. An increase in funding would also allow NINR to establish an
initiative consistent with the recommendations of the Congressionally established Diabetes Research
Working Group. The specific focus would be to intensify clinical behavioral research to improve both
patient adherence to diabetes treatment and quality of life. These interventions will result in lifestyle
behaviors which will effectively reduce the risk of developing complications of diabetes or delay their
onset. While we support the Administration's proposed 3.3 percent increase above FY 2000
funding of $90 million for this program, we recommend a $20 million increase to fund NINR at
$110 million.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) Clinical Training Program
The SAMHSA Clinical Training Program has been a major source of the nation's mental health clinical
training funds, and is a source of funding for ANA's Minority Fellowship Project (MFP). The funding
is allocated through SAMHSA to the minority mental health training programs in nursing, psychology,
social work and psychiatry. The MFP graduates have an outstanding record of public service to minority
and indigent communities.
MFP graduates receive doctoral degrees and, as clinicians, work in high risk urban and rural areas
providing care to children and families who are victims of violence, HIV/AIDS, and substance abuse as
well as the mentally ill. These nurses work in community based clinics and outreach programs and often
are the primary care providers for indigent clients who might otherwise go without needed mental health
services. In addition, MFP graduates generate research on minority mental health services, treatments
and client outcomes. Culturally appropriate research helps us to identify ways to provide services faster
and to more people, ultimately improving health care outcomes and reducing health care costs. This
works to change the poor health outcomes and high risk health status that continues to plague minority
communities. These graduates also work as teachers in schools of nursing that serve minority students,
serving as role models and providing leadership to future nurses. We believe this program is a good
investment in reducing mental health care costs and recommend funding of $5.0 million for FY
2001 for the SAMHSA Clinical Training program.
AIDS Education and Training Centers(AETC)
The AETC program in the Bureau of Health Professions at the Health Resources and Services
Administration provides specialized training for health care personnel who care for patients with AIDS.
Emerging and evolving scientific information with profound impact on individual and public health
requires a ready network for information dissemination and technology transfer. AETCs reduce care
costs by increasing treatment and care expertise which serves to ease the suffering of families and
communities. It is for this reason that we support the National Organization Responding to AIDS
Coalition's (NORA) recommended FY 2001 funding level of $30.3 million for the AETCs.
The National Institutes for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)
NIOSH is the only federal agency with the mission to conduct research and develop practical solutions
to prevent work injury and illness. NIOSH played a key scientific role in the development of the blood
borne pathogens standard which provides significant protection to front-line health care providers from
possible exposure to blood borne pathogens, such as HIV, Hepatitis-B and Hepatitis-C. In addition,
NIOSH funds Educational Resource Centers. These multi-disciplinary, university based occupational
health and safety training and research centers are the primary vehicle for the development and training
of a corps of trained occupational health nurses and other safety professionals. We recommend FY
2001 funding of $285 million for NIOSH.
Racial/Ethnic Health Care Disparities
A recent report of the United States Commission on Civil Rights, "The Health Care Challenge:
Acknowledging Disparity, Confronting Discrimination, and Ensuring Equality" September 1999,
examined the racial, ethnic and gender disparities in health status, health research, access to health
services, and health care financing. "The Commission found that despite efforts to eliminate
discrimination and improve access to health care for minorities and women, there has been little change
in the quality of, or access to, health care for members of this group." It is in response to ANA's
concerns regarding these continued disparities that ANA supports funding recommendations outlined
in the document prepared by the Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities Coalition.
OTHER WORKFORCE FUNDING RECOMMENDATIONS:
As an advocate for the economic and general welfare of registered nurses, the American Nurses
Association also recommends appropriate funding for the Department of Labor and related agencies
that serve to ensure a safe and fair workplace. ANA believes the work done by the Bureau of Labor
Statistics, with respect to the ongoing collection and analysis of employment and economic data, is
necessary for tracking changing economic conditions and essential to making workforce projections.
We urge your support of the Bureau.
National Labor Relations Board (NLRB)
ANA is concerned about the ability of the NLRB to meet its statutory responsibility of enforcing and
interpreting the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). Potential delays in the processing of complaints
and holding representation elections may jeopardize the progress in employee and employer relations.
ANA considers this a core independent agency function that must be preserved. We support the
Administration's recommended FY 2001 funding of $216 million for the NLRB.
Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
The rapid restructuring of the health industry has increased, and in some cases exacerbated, the risk of
exposure to illness and injury for nurses and other health care workers. Hospitals and HMOs are
downsizing both to cut costs and be competitive in the health care marketplace. These economic
pressures have led to a reduction in the number of registered nurses providing care at the bedside. The
remaining nurses in these acute care settings have to work harder and take care of more and sicker
patients than ever before. The nurses themselves are sustaining more frequent incidences of injury and
illness. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in 1993, back and shoulder injuries accounted for
50 percent of the 31,422 injuries and illnesses that kept registered nurses away from work. Overall,
lifting was specified as the cause of 26 percent of all registered nurse injuries. ANA is concerned about
the increased occupational risks in nursing and their negative effect on nurses today and the future of
this profession.
ANA continues to be concerned about the strength of the Office of Occupational Health Nursing and
its parity with similar offices. Occupational health nurses are the largest group of health care providers
at the nation's work sites. As such, they are uniquely qualified to assess the practical realities of work
sites and related regulatory activities. This office must be fully staffed in order to accomplish its critical
task of linking the ongoing work of occupational safety and health nurses to OSHA. We support the
Administration's recommendation for FY 2001 funding of $426 million for OSHA.
Conclusion
We appreciate the opportunity to comment on funding for nursing education, research and workforce
programs. We thank you for your continued support and look forward to working with you as you
proceed through the appropriations process.
Return to the testimony listing.
Return to the Legislative Branch.
|